Which picture you get
An ICO file holds the same picture at several sizes, often 16, 32, 48 and 256 pixels. The largest one is saved, since it has the most detail, and the result names how many sizes the icon held. To get a smaller size, use the image resizer on the PNG afterwards.
Old and new icons
Icons made since Windows XP store their sizes as 32-bit pictures with transparency, and since Windows Vista often the largest as PNG; older ones use a colour table and a mask for the see-through parts. Both kinds open here, and the PNG keeps the transparency either way.
The new files are made in your browser from your images. Nothing is uploaded, and location and camera details (EXIF) are left out.